Alan MacDiarmid, Ralph Connor Memorial Lecture
- 2001
These captions and transcript were generated by a computer and may contain errors. If there are significant errors that should be corrected, please let us know by emailing digital@sciencehistory.org.
Transcript
00:00:01 Ray Bowman, a very distinguished Harvard Ph.D. fellow of the Russian Academy of Natural Sciences,
00:00:10 fellow of the American Philosophical Society, friend and colleague in the conducting polymers area to Alan MacDiarmid.
00:00:18 Ray.
00:00:20 Thank you, Ray.
00:00:28 It is, of course, a special pleasure and honor for me to introduce today's speaker.
00:00:36 Actually, I'm afraid not because Ray's sitting here.
00:00:41 For the Ralph Connor Memorial Lecture, of course, this is Professor Alan MacDiarmid from the University of Pennsylvania.
00:00:50 It is a special pleasure and honor for me because of the nature of Alan as both a man and as a scientist.
00:01:00 I'd like to talk about Alan, introduce Alan by talking about him both as a man and as a scientist.
00:01:09 Of course, most of you know that recently Professor Alan MacDiarmid, Professor Hideki Shirakawa,
00:01:17 and Professor Alan Hegar showed the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for the discovery of conducting polymers.
00:01:24 This type of event often elicits mixed feelings of different people around the world.
00:01:31 There's jealousies of people.
00:01:33 This is completely the opposite of what happened in the case of Alan.
00:01:43 The world was dancing with joy as they heard about Alan sharing the Nobel Prize.
00:01:51 People, as they woke up all around the world, called me all times of the day and night to say,
00:01:58 Did you hear the news that Alan has the Nobel Prize?
00:02:03 Alan MacDiarmid, Alan Hegar, Hideki Shirakawa, people were calling me from Brazil, from Europe, from Japan, from Australia.
00:02:17 Gordon Wallace called me from Australia and said, and this was about 3 o'clock in America he called me,
00:02:25 and he says, Ray, I just learned that Alan MacDiarmid has gotten the Nobel Prize.
00:02:30 He says, no one's around. I must tell someone.
00:02:35 This is the level of excitement, and this level reflects, of course, Alan as a scientist, but it also reflects Alan as a man.
00:02:44 And, of course, our other close friends and colleagues, Alan Hegar and Alan MacDiarmid and Hideki Shirakawa,
00:02:54 this Nobel Prize, of course, is a result of all of their contributions.
00:03:00 It's a result of Alan MacDiarmid's inquisitiveness when he saw a film in Japan produced by Hideki Shirakawa,
00:03:10 which was metallic-looking, silvery, it looked pretty.
00:03:14 His scientific curiosity, his interest in beauty resulted in him bringing Hideki back to the United States,
00:03:27 and then the three of them together worked to make what is the first Kentucky Polymer, a very exciting event for mankind.
00:03:36 Now, okay, we know that Alan got the Nobel Prize with Hideki Shirakawa and Alan Hegar for discovery of the first Kentucky Polymer.
00:03:46 But then I went back in the literature and I said, let's take Alan's papers and just, by their topic, divide them according to the topic.
00:03:55 If you look at my topic, the first topic word, many of them deal with applications.
00:04:02 I mean, Alan just didn't synthesize beautiful polymers and characterize their properties.
00:04:07 He really, some of the major applications of conducting polymers, many of them, Alan MacDiarmid and coworkers,
00:04:17 were the first to have any demonstration in that area.
00:04:21 For example, in batteries, Alan has 20 patents.
00:04:25 My research group became very interested in this discovery as people all around the world was becoming interested in it.
00:04:32 We built up a business relationship with Alan in this area.
00:04:38 These batteries actually were commercialized in Japan.
00:04:41 Area of lighting, many displays, even though Alan, this is one of the few areas where Alan didn't make the first device.
00:04:49 But even in this area, he had many publications and many inventions, many, actually new types of devices resulted from Alan's work.
00:04:57 I could go on, but I'm afraid I'm only supposed to talk six minutes and I will try not to.
00:05:03 I could go on for hours talking about Alan's inventiveness, which was not what was awarded at the Nobel, honored at the Nobel Prize.
00:05:12 But this is for his next Nobel Prize.
00:05:16 He is always, and this is only, I'm missing many things here, but I just have this list, for example, with Art Epstein,
00:05:27 Alan's technology with Art for welding polymers together using conducting polymers, microwave absorption for them,
00:05:35 and most recently the company that Alan is starting in making cheap electronic circuits using a process that he invented,
00:05:43 his nanospinning technology.
00:05:45 I could go on for hours, but you didn't come to listen to me talk, listen to Alan talk, so I won't go on for hours,
00:05:52 but I will continue, probably until I'm full from this coding thing.
00:05:59 Alan's inventions have even reached the comics.
00:06:02 This is from a newspaper in Puerto Rico where Alan, of course, at the discovery,
00:06:10 Nobel Prize winning discovery of conducting polymers, eventually led to conducting polymers that were highly conducting
00:06:16 and at the same time transparent.
00:06:18 And the story here is the individual is fascinated with the fact of a transparent conductor of cable for the TV
00:06:28 and eventually ends up being that.
00:06:30 And they talk about Alan McDiarmid's inventions.
00:06:34 But another aspect that I never heard Alan talk ever publicly about was amazing to me.
00:06:42 A long time ago, in the early days of conducting polymers, when I had all my hair,
00:06:47 Alan's students ran into him and said,
00:06:52 Ah, Professor McDiarmid, the acetylene gas has liquefied.
00:06:57 And Alan says, Ah!
00:06:59 So they called the fire department and because acetylene is a very highly energetic material,
00:07:07 if it condenses in either liquid or solid form, it's an extremely hazardous explosive.
00:07:13 So they evacuated the building.
00:07:16 Normally you think the fire department handles these things.
00:07:20 Alan McDiarmid, they suited up Alan McDiarmid with all this explosive equipment
00:07:25 and Alan walked over to the equipment and himself turned the valve, diffused the bomb.
00:07:34 Again, Alan is a man for all times, science and otherwise, and this is just an example.
00:07:42 Again, Alan's ability and interest in people is really a major motivating force in this area.
00:07:52 I can think of decades of Alan's being in front of posters with students
00:08:01 and trying to think of something that he could praise.
00:08:04 And I always remember Alan coming up with, Ah, that is so interesting and meaningful
00:08:11 because he's talked to the person for so long that he understands that there is something here to be excited about.
00:08:20 And this has encouraged generations of scientists, including myself.
00:08:25 This is a case where Alan very recently was talking at the University of Texas at Dallas.
00:08:34 He was talking to young students and he personally signed these certificates for each one of them
00:08:41 and insisted that they hold the Nobel Prize when they were given their certificate
00:08:47 and photographs were taken.
00:08:50 So Texas now has more Nobel Prize holders than any place in the world.
00:08:59 This is a quotation actually from a friend of mine.
00:09:02 That's one friend who is also from the University of Pennsylvania.
00:09:07 We're not from the University of Pennsylvania, it's from the Philadelphia area.
00:09:11 Now, even at the Nobel Prize ceremony, Alan continued to teach.
00:09:23 And this was a ceremony, the last ceremony of the Nobel Prize events.
00:09:29 This is a, I forgot what they officially call it, but it goes from 12 at night until 5 in the morning.
00:09:38 Nightcare.
00:09:39 Nightcare.
00:09:40 And Alan has many people, not only science, but also aspects of living.
00:09:50 And Alan did a very special Mari dance at the Nobel Prize post ceremonies.
00:09:58 That is, I think, very characteristic of Alan.
00:10:02 He comes from New Zealand and these are the Mari, an aboriginal tribe.
00:10:06 This is a war dance that, or a dance in some cases of life, because there's aspects of this that I can't go into.
00:10:16 And I might even have got the words for the wrong Mari dance, but I hope I can write a Mari dance.
00:10:21 But Alan, at this dance, at the ceremony, post ceremony, nightcap, Alan did his famous Mari dance.
00:10:34 And the Mari dance, you must dance with your soul.
00:10:38 And Alan was truly dancing with his soul.
00:10:41 The whole student population just converged on Alan.
00:10:45 They ignored all the other Nobel Prize winners when they saw what type of man they had in their midst.
00:10:51 And this is Alan doing the Mari dance.
00:10:55 I've already spoken too long before someone actually does pull me from the stage, from the podium.
00:11:01 I'd like to say this, of course, is Professor Alan McDiarmid, Professor of the University of Pennsylvania at Blanchard,
00:11:10 Professor Nobel Laureate, who will be talking about research and development of industry.
00:11:15 Thank you.
00:11:17 Thank you.
00:11:24 It's a pleasure it is to be here this evening.
00:11:27 I've met so many old friends and colleagues, and I was just saying to Ray a few minutes ago,
00:11:34 I think probably I have the pleasure of knowing personally about 50% if not more of everybody in this room.
00:11:42 I just feel I'm amongst old friends, colleagues, students.
00:11:47 So I just want to say thank you for coming.
00:11:50 It just really is wonderful, wonderful for me.
00:11:54 One of the key things when Ray, apart from the war dance, when Ray and I, I guess,
00:12:04 have been collaborating on and off for more than a couple of decades.
00:12:11 And I've learned so much from Ray as being a member of Ray being in the industry, myself in academia.
00:12:20 And this has taught me so much about how people work and think in the academic field.
00:12:31 Also, I feel particularly close and very, very honored to be participating in this first lecture,
00:12:43 in the lecture series, in honor of Ralph Conner.
00:12:47 Since Ralph, of course, as Arnold mentioned earlier, was a member of the chemistry department at Penn
00:12:55 before he became a leader in the development of Rohm and Haas.
00:13:01 And, of course, Rohm and Haas is our own big, heavy chemical industry of Philadelphia.
00:13:08 And also my relationship to this wonderful chemical heritage foundation is very closely related to Charlie Price,
00:13:22 who Arnold mentioned earlier, that Charlie hired me, sight unseen,
00:13:29 as a new, very junior member of the chemistry department at Penn 45 years ago.
00:13:36 So I have the relationships this evening both with Rohm and Haas, Ralph Conner,
00:13:44 and the chemical heritage foundation through Charlie Price.
00:13:48 So there are a lot of very, very warm feelings with my being here.
00:13:54 The Nobel Prize then awarded to Alan Hegar, a physicist when he was at Penn,
00:14:06 Hideki Shirakawa from Tokyo Institute of Technology,
00:14:11 and to myself, I think is of special significance worldwide in that it highlights the importance of interdisciplinary research,
00:14:23 which, as we all know, interdisciplinary research is becoming more important as every moment goes by.
00:14:31 And this collaboration for the discovery of synthetic metals or electronic polymers,
00:14:39 whichever we want to call them, has been stated by some to be one of the best examples in recent years of collaborative research.
00:14:49 So here we have, in this case, two chemists and one physicist.
00:14:55 In past years, the chemists would do chemistry research, the physicists would do physics research,
00:15:01 and they hardly would speak to each other because they did not know each other's scientific language.
00:15:07 And so here we have a case of all persons working together,
00:15:11 and, of course, quite often, in cases such as this, one plus one actually makes more than two.
00:15:20 Now, I wanted to touch very briefly tonight on some of the aspects of our research,
00:15:29 which have developed into various types of industrial aspects.
00:15:37 But first of all, I thought I would digress just for some more light-hearted and also serious aspects of the Nobel Prize.
00:15:48 I think, as we all know, Alfred Nobel amassed a very, very large fortune.
00:15:57 He was born in Sweden in 1833 and died in 1896.
00:16:03 And he had been working on what was called blasting oil.
00:16:11 This was nitroglycerin, and he had some factories in which blasting oil was manufactured.
00:16:18 But, unfortunately, there were some very terrible explosions,
00:16:22 and his brother, who was working with him, lost his life in one of these explosions.
00:16:27 Then later, Alfred Nobel found that if you mix the blasting oil with Kieselger,
00:16:35 a clay-type material made from the silicaceous skeletons of diatoms,
00:16:41 then it still would have the blasting properties, but the spontaneous explosive properties were not present.
00:16:52 And it's said that you can take, then, a stick of dynamite made from this,
00:16:56 and you can light it and burn it like a candle,
00:17:00 but I have not been sufficiently brave and experimental to try and do that myself.
00:17:05 So, then, Nobel left his very substantial will for those persons whom the Special Nobel Committee,
00:17:18 which was created, were deemed to have contributed, by their research,
00:17:25 to various fields of life which benefited humanity overall.
00:17:34 And this, then, is a list of the six areas in which the Nobel Prizes are awarded.
00:17:41 As of this year, the three persons in the physics area and chemistry, Alan Hegar,
00:17:46 who was at Penn until about 10 or 12 years ago, when he went to the University of California,
00:17:52 and Hideki Shirakawa, who was at the Tokyo Institute of Technology and then Tsukuba University,
00:18:00 and he joined us for a year.
00:18:02 And one of the more unusual things about this joint awarding was that, normally, in the past,
00:18:10 usually in the past, when joint awards are made, these are awarded to persons who are from different institutions
00:18:19 or from different countries, and they get to know each other from meeting at scientific meetings
00:18:25 or by reading the literature.
00:18:27 However, in our case, all of the key work was done, all at Penn, in three different laboratories,
00:18:35 one in chemistry, my lab, one in the Laboratory for Research on the Structure of Matter,
00:18:41 and the other in the physics department.
00:18:43 So it is, we are told, rather unusual to have all persons involved working together in the same university
00:18:52 and in the same laboratories.
00:18:55 And then we have the various other areas here.
00:19:01 And you will note that mathematics is missing.
00:19:05 I've read in one or two publications, and of course one always can believe what one reads in the literature,
00:19:12 that no prize was awarded in mathematics because Alfred Nobel's sweetheart ran off with a mathematician.
00:19:24 But the stories go that the mathematician got the greatest award of all, he got Alfred Nobel's sweetheart.
00:19:33 However, that can be controversial.
00:19:37 But I think one of the important points here is from all of these research groups,
00:19:43 and referring back to our own one, the Nobel Prize here, then, is recognition.
00:19:52 of the wonderful work which persons throughout the world have done.
00:19:57 For example, the type of work which Ray Bachman and his group have done
00:20:02 has contributed so enormously to this prize.
00:20:09 Indeed, if it had not been for all of the work in various groups throughout the world
00:20:14 which has put this whole field on the map,
00:20:17 there would be no prize that would have been given.
00:20:21 And as we all know, the work which comes out of a given research group
00:20:26 cannot be better than those individual people carrying out the research in the lab.
00:20:33 So there are a large number of people in this room, I know, at the moment
00:20:38 who have, with their own two hands and intelligence and initiative and perseverance,
00:20:45 have very substantially contributed to the award.
00:20:49 Indeed, several people in this room.
00:20:54 Just to mention something which is never officially made public,
00:21:02 but it's sort of fun to mention it.
00:21:05 This is where I was receiving the award from the King of Sweden,
00:21:12 and if you'll bear with me for about 100 seconds,
00:21:15 I'll go into something which I had never heard about
00:21:18 and I think which most people in the world have not heard about.
00:21:21 And that is that the Nobel laureates are sitting in a semicircle here,
00:21:28 the King and the Queen and the Royal Family are sitting in another semicircle over there,
00:21:32 the Royal Swedish Academy of Science members up there, they vote on the award,
00:21:38 and then the audience is sitting out there.
00:21:41 And it's an extremely formal affair, as we are told by the academy and the Nobel Foundation,
00:21:50 that they say that this portion of the award ceremony is actually seen by,
00:21:57 at one time or another, by one third of the world's population,
00:22:02 by about 2 billion people, either from various parts of television
00:22:07 or from the worldwide web on which the whole ceremony is given.
00:22:12 Anyway, we have a very, very formal practice session in the morning at 10 o'clock
00:22:19 for about two hours when the award ceremony is at 4 o'clock in the afternoon.
00:22:23 And at one point we were very strongly impressed on this.
00:22:29 You watch the King.
00:22:31 When the King stands, you must stand.
00:22:35 When the King sits, you must sit.
00:22:38 You cannot be standing if the King is sitting.
00:22:40 You cannot be sitting if the King is standing.
00:22:42 So then, in my case, the same with all of the others,
00:22:47 the King stands and I stand, and there's a big circle in the middle of the floor,
00:22:52 and the King and I are then meant to reach that circle at the same time.
00:22:58 And we're all wearing sort of tie and tails, of course.
00:23:02 And then he hands me two things here.
00:23:05 Now, these two things, I only brought one of them with me.
00:23:09 The thing on the bottom is a very, very nice diploma thing.
00:23:15 The thing on the top is this little leather case which holds the Nobel Medal,
00:23:22 which I've never seen one in my life until this occasion.
00:23:26 And it's in a very, very nice, shiny leather case.
00:23:31 Now, the King, as you can see here, has his right hand on the top of it.
00:23:37 And I read somewhere recently that somebody had calculated
00:23:43 that every person in the world, so every person in this room,
00:23:46 has approximately two molecules of water, which were, at one time or another,
00:23:52 in Julius Caesar's body.
00:23:54 So, if one is to reflect from that, since this was such a everybody is scared stiff year,
00:24:00 I'm sure that the King of Sweden's hand was a bit sweaty.
00:24:04 So, when he put his hand on the top, some of his sweat got absorbed into the leather.
00:24:09 So, as I've said, anyone then who comes along and does that will take their hand away
00:24:15 and will have some molecules of sweat from the King of Sweden's hand.
00:24:19 But what I will do, it is sort of fun.
00:24:26 It's, of course, a solid gold medal.
00:24:30 I've never touched a piece of gold before, which is bigger than a gold filling
00:24:34 that has fallen out of my hand.
00:24:37 So, I'll leave this up here if anybody wants to get some of the King of Sweden's sweat.
00:24:44 And also the medal.
00:24:46 And as I've been informed, Arnold has put special metal detectors
00:24:51 all of the gold outside.
00:24:56 Anyway, just to comment here then.
00:25:02 What I would like to do here is to briefly go through
00:25:08 from the initial, some of the initial discoveries in the area of electronic polymers
00:25:18 or conducting polymers and leading through to some industrial developments
00:25:24 which I personally have been involved with.
00:25:29 And just to see how things can develop along.
00:25:34 And in this respect then, one can have a brief outline.
00:25:42 And we will be talking then about synthetic metals or electronic polymers
00:25:47 and I'll make a distinction between those two things in a moment.
00:25:50 And here we are talking about intrinsically conducting organic polymers.
00:25:56 Some previously, a lot of very good work had been done
00:26:02 by mixing in graphite powder, carbon powder, or small metal particles,
00:26:09 nickel particles in with a conventional polymer.
00:26:13 And these small conducting particles would touch each other
00:26:17 and so therefore you had a polymer which would conduct electricity
00:26:21 but it was just a composite, a mixture of conducting particles
00:26:26 embedded in a conventional polymer which was insulated.
00:26:30 But here we are talking about intrinsically conducting.
00:26:34 And when I mention conducting, we are talking about electronically conducting,
00:26:39 not ionically conducting.
00:26:41 As we all know, if you have something which is ionically conducting,
00:26:45 there is actually a movement of mass.
00:26:47 For example, if you are electrolyzing a solution of salt in water or molten steel chloride.
00:26:53 But if one assumes that the mass of an electron is negligible,
00:26:57 then electronic conductivity occurs without the movement of any mass.
00:27:04 So, as pointed out by Professor Randi, a famous European polymer chemist,
00:27:16 that the whole area of organic polymers can be subdivided into two categories.
00:27:24 One, those before pre-1977, electrically insulating,
00:27:30 being studied for many of the good and very important reasons
00:27:36 and to study the properties.
00:27:38 And then post-1977, when the field of electrically conducting polymers
00:27:48 came to life here at Cairn.
00:27:53 And the distinction which I have been making in the last couple of years
00:27:59 is to distinguish between the generic class of electronic polymers and the good polymers.
00:28:07 In the last couple of, or three or four or five years,
00:28:11 electronic polymers, normally conducting, conducting in the semiconducting rate regime,
00:28:16 have become extremely important as light-emitting diodes, as LEDs.
00:28:22 And these are the things we looked at, first of all,
00:28:26 that did not seem to be particularly interesting.
00:28:29 We find we can then dope these to the metallic conducting regime and also undope them.
00:28:35 And I often like to describe to the non-scientists what one means by doping.
00:28:41 And what I use quite often as an analogy is to say,
00:28:46 let's imagine that we have a white angel food cake.
00:28:50 And let's say that we're going to add one drop of red coloring matter to that.
00:28:55 Now that one drop may be perhaps one millionth or one ten millionth the volume of the cake.
00:29:01 And yet that one drop changes the optical properties of the cake completely from white to pink.
00:29:08 So we can consider when we add certain chemicals, either chemically or electrochemically,
00:29:14 to certain types of conjugated polymers that we can call a dopant.
00:29:21 We can also here remove the dopant.
00:29:25 And on occasion people have asked me, well, how do you remove the traces of red coloring matter from the cake?
00:29:31 And then I say, time to move on to discuss that.
00:29:36 So the conductivity range covers the whole range,
00:29:44 the conductivity range that one can reach with conducting polyvinyl
00:29:49 covers the whole spread from insulators like quartz, nylon, Teflon down here,
00:29:56 up to the best metals, conducting metals of good temperature, copper, silver, gold.
00:30:02 And then in the intermediate range of conductivity, semiconductors, silicon, germanium, etc.
00:30:09 And here we have then the polyacetylene, the first type of conducting polymer which we looked at.
00:30:20 Conductivity ranging from about 10 to the power of minus 5 Siemens per centimeter,
00:30:27 which in a few minutes at room temperature by, for example, iodine vapor,
00:30:32 can have its conductivity increased by 10 orders of magnitude to about 10 to the power of plus 5 in the metallic regime.
00:30:40 And more recently, we and others have been looking at polyaniline,
00:30:45 which is built by a different method from the conductivity of about 10 to the power of minus 10,
00:30:51 up to 10 to the power of plus 3, an increase in conductivity of about 13 orders of magnitude.
00:30:58 And the polyaniline is now the industrially most important conducting polymer
00:31:05 from the point of view of the quantity of metal.
00:31:08 And indeed, Ray here was the key person with a vision when his company was called Allied Signal, I guess,
00:31:20 got together the first commercial production of polyaniline.
00:31:28 Now, one sometimes might say, okay, this is all fine, this is all old stuff,
00:31:35 the field, everything exciting has been found out, and the field is sort of dead now.
00:31:40 Let's move on to some more exciting things.
00:31:43 However, the field is extraordinarily alive, as, for example, was shown at the Materials Research Society meeting last November,
00:31:52 where superconductivity in an organic polymer was reported for the first time.
00:32:00 This is something that all of us have been looking for and never expecting to find,
00:32:05 something like searching for the Holy Grail, you constantly look, but you never really expect to find it.
00:32:11 This was discovered by Matt Larkin at Lucette Technologies, the old spin-off from Bell Labs,
00:32:17 where a polythiophene conducting polymer was found to become superconducting at low temperature,
00:32:26 about 2 Kelvin, and only a very thin layer of it, but conceptually it opens a whole new ballpark.
00:32:37 So, things are changing rapidly, and I'll touch briefly on some of the other aspects, we'll see how rapidly that is going.
00:32:45 So, conducting polymers, then, have the electrical, magnetic, and conductivity properties, optical properties of the metal,
00:33:00 while retaining the flexibility and processability of regular commercial polymers.
00:33:07 And the doping, either chemically or electrochemically, and we found that polyacetylene could be doped either chemically or electrochemically,
00:33:18 is the key sort of connecting thread that pulls all of this class of polymers together.
00:33:26 And there are other types of doping, charge injection doping, which we do not have time to mention at the moment.
00:33:34 So, polyacetylene, then, as I think Ray was mentioning, it's an intriguing thing to look at,
00:33:45 and my whole interest in science has nearly always been guided by color.
00:33:51 Now, in other words, polyacetylene, a just common acetylene welding gas in a zig-zag catalyst,
00:34:00 can be converted to these beautiful, really beautiful silvery films.
00:34:08 The side, you just have a glass tube about that diameter, put in about this long,
00:34:15 put in about five cc's of tetra-butoxy-titanium triethylaluminum, which I know Georgia has done on many occasions,
00:34:23 and shake it up, you wet the inside walls of the tube, and one limits the settling gas,
00:34:32 and you get the film forming in just a few minutes.
00:34:35 And the side of the film, close to the glass, is bright and silvery.
00:34:39 That on the inside is more dull.
00:34:41 It's got powder of powdery polyacetylene.
00:34:44 I can wipe it with a cream extender, but it's silvery also.
00:34:47 And this discovery, which really was the fundamental first thing that got this whole field worldwide going,
00:35:00 was due to a misunderstanding between the Korean and the Japanese language.
00:35:05 And Hidetoshi Shirakawa, one of the awardees of the prize, was a junior faculty member at Tokyo Institute of Technology,
00:35:14 and he had a new Korean student come and join his group, and as it's understandable,
00:35:19 people with different languages sometimes have some difficulty in interacting.
00:35:26 Shirakawa had been polymerizing this with this catalyst,
00:35:32 and had always finished up with rather an uninteresting black-brown powder.
00:35:37 So the new student came in, and Shirakawa said,
00:35:40 please make some more of this black-brown powder,
00:35:43 and make up this catalyst so many millimolar in toluene.
00:35:49 The student came back a few days later and said the stirring bar will not go around.
00:35:53 So Shirakawa went into the lab, and sure enough, the stirring bar did not go around,
00:35:59 and instead there were some blobs of sort of pink jelly looking very silvery floating around.
00:36:07 So he said to the student, what did you do?
00:36:09 And the student said, I did exactly as you told me.
00:36:12 I made up the catalyst so many molar.
00:36:16 In other words, he made it up molar instead of millimolar.
00:36:20 So he made up the catalyst a thousand times concentrated,
00:36:23 and that really started off the whole field.
00:36:27 And then Shirakawa joined us, and we started looking at the chemistry of some of these things,
00:36:35 and then Alan Higa, very kindly,
00:36:38 then started looking at some of the physical measurements,
00:36:43 which we were not capable of doing.
00:36:47 And we found that if one took a film of the polyacetylene with silvery film exposure to iodine vapor,
00:36:55 and iodine does not have much of a vacant pressure at room temperature for just a few minutes,
00:37:01 the conductivity would increase by about 10 orders of magnitude
00:37:05 from the semiconducting regime up to the metallic regime.
00:37:09 And the positive charge is delocalized.
00:37:13 About 85% of the positive charge is delocalized over about 15 CH units,
00:37:20 and that makes it relatively stable.
00:37:23 And the conductivity increases.
00:37:26 And one of the ways I like to regard the increase in conductivity by this doping
00:37:32 is if we take the analogy with a city square crowded with people so you can hardly move.
00:37:39 And let's imagine that people and electrons are synonymous.
00:37:43 So if a person in the city square wants to move from this side to this,
00:37:47 he or she is going to have great difficulty in doing that.
00:37:51 But if you remove some of the people from the city square,
00:37:54 then the person can go much more easily from one side to the other.
00:37:58 So it is here in the backbone, in the pi backbone of the polyacetylene,
00:38:03 the electrons are very crowded.
00:38:06 You remove some of them, and then it gives them breathing space,
00:38:09 and the electrons can move more easily, so you then have a flow of an electric current.
00:38:14 And we found that we could remove electrons by electrochemically,
00:38:20 like attaching a couple of flashlight batteries together.
00:38:25 And we call this p-doping because p for positive, we were removing electrons
00:38:31 and causing a positive hole.
00:38:34 And similarly we found we could do the n-type doping, n for negative,
00:38:39 and we could put in electrons by using sodium to give up electrons,
00:38:44 or we could do that electrochemically.
00:38:47 And the electrons went into the empty anti-bonding pi star backbone orbitals,
00:38:53 so there were no electrons there before.
00:38:56 Now they have a few, so these electrons could then move around
00:39:00 and use their conductivity at work.
00:39:03 Then shortly thereafter, and this is where Ray Bachman again came in
00:39:10 with extraordinarily important work,
00:39:13 that Ray then found that we could join benzene rings together,
00:39:18 and also these could be p or n-doped chemically or electrochemically,
00:39:22 and why this was so very important was that up to Ray's work here,
00:39:28 one wondered whether this conversion of polyacetylene, a polyene,
00:39:36 to this highly conducting state, whether that was just specific to that one compound.
00:39:41 But Ray's work showed you could take a completely different type of polymer
00:39:45 and get the same effect, and then this opened up the whole thing.
00:39:48 a whole area to the people's minds that one might be able to find this in a whole variety of other things.
00:39:58 And so the whole field progressed.
00:40:01 The doping we've talked about so far we have called redox doping because you're either production or oxidation
00:40:08 you're adding or removing electrons from the chain.
00:40:12 But the polyaniline which is actually the world's oldest known synthetic polymer
00:40:20 first mentioned in the Journal of the Chemical Society in about 1832
00:40:26 this is dope to the highly conducting regime just by simple acid-base propanation
00:40:33 and we will not go into that now because we don't have time
00:40:39 but one can dissolve it in organic solvent such as NMP
00:40:47 pour the solution onto a glass plate, put it into an oven, evaporate the solvent
00:40:52 and then one is left with really very, very nice films.
00:40:57 This is one of the polyaniline in a non-dipped state, it's air-stable
00:41:02 I've been carrying this around for several years, exposed to air.
00:41:05 You put this into dilute HCL or for high school students I've used, say, put it into vinegar
00:41:12 and then it's converted into metallic polyaniline
00:41:18 and this has a very great purple, glittery appearance.
00:41:24 So it's, there are many, many things that one can envisage.
00:41:33 So now in the remainder of time I'd like to touch more on the technological aspects
00:41:39 and the application and making of certain companies from some of these basic concepts here.
00:41:47 So we cannot then act the technological applications
00:41:52 but I want to stress very much indeed that I think all of us,
00:42:00 regardless of whether we're in academia, industry, government labs,
00:42:04 we get a real intellectual pleasure from the science.
00:42:09 So sometimes when I'm talking about this area
00:42:13 people will politely listen to some of the chemistry
00:42:16 and then when they think they've listened long enough
00:42:18 they'll say, oh yes, very interesting, but what is it used for?
00:42:23 To which I reply, I say, what use is a beautiful piece of poetry?
00:42:29 What use is a beautiful piece of poetry?
00:42:32 So my feeling is that one can get real intellectual pleasure
00:42:38 and enjoyment from unexpected new science.
00:42:44 If that new science can have a technological use on top of that
00:42:49 then that's icing on the cake.
00:42:53 But one can get the enjoyment from the science itself.
00:43:01 Now I've listed here just a few areas which are now well underway.
00:43:07 I will mention some of these and then I'll spend the last few minutes
00:43:11 on the very, very recent areas which are now going forward.
00:43:16 Now the light-emitting devices, this is, I think, tremendously exciting.
00:43:23 In other words, if one puts three 10 volts DC across thin films
00:43:31 of various types of electronic polymers
00:43:33 they give out intense light of various colours.
00:43:37 The colours are, the intensity is brighter than that in many cases
00:43:43 than that of a television screen, brighter than a fluorescent light.
00:43:48 There are several, it was first discovered in Richard Friend's lab
00:43:52 in Cambridge in 1990 and so now 11 years later
00:43:59 Richard Friend started a company, Cambridge Display Company
00:44:04 which he sold last year, at least in the Wall Street Journal,
00:44:09 for about 90 million pounds.
00:44:12 So it took them about 10 years to develop this finding in the lab
00:44:17 and it was accidental also.
00:44:22 And now it's next year, or rather this year,
00:44:26 they will be coming out with some actual devices which I'll mention.
00:44:30 My colleague Alan Hegar then, when he left Penn and went to Santa Barbara
00:44:38 he started his own company, Uniax Company,
00:44:42 where he started developing technologically
00:44:45 these basic discoveries we and others have found
00:44:49 and also making beautiful light-emitting diodes
00:44:53 and he sold his company, Uniax, to DuPont about six months ago
00:44:59 for an undisclosed sum.
00:45:02 But they also will be having actual devices coming out
00:45:06 and I was at a meeting in Brazil about two weeks ago
00:45:11 when Kodak, Dave Williams, showed beautiful flat-screen
00:45:17 high-colour, high-definition displays
00:45:20 all made from these organic materials.
00:45:25 The first use in which two companies will be cutting
00:45:31 these light-emitting diodes out this year are in cellular phones.
00:45:36 Those of us who use cellular phones in the driving home at night
00:45:42 know it's a real pain when you can't see it.
00:45:45 So these will have coloured illuminated screen backgrounds the whole time.
00:45:52 Also, the actual hours of operation with these light-emitting diodes screens
00:46:03 will be greater than with the liquid crystal.
00:46:05 Also, it's quite remarkable, as we know,
00:46:10 if you have a liquid crystal screen, whether it's on your computer,
00:46:13 you look at it straight on but when you're moving it sideways
00:46:16 you can't see anything.
00:46:18 These are really remarkable.
00:46:19 You can have it almost at this angle and you can still see what is there.
00:46:25 So it is believed that these, from the point of view of cost and efficiency,
00:46:30 will, at least those in the field say,
00:46:34 will certainly rapidly displace liquid crystal displays.
00:46:41 One of the things which is being very actively covered
00:46:47 is completely flexible screens,
00:46:50 which you can sort of roll up and put them in a pocket,
00:46:53 they'll outbreak, they won't break.
00:46:54 And I'll mention shortly about the electronics wiring
00:47:00 being behind it, completely flexible.
00:47:03 And many of these completely throw away electronics,
00:47:08 paper, plastic, fabric,
00:47:11 and maybe use once and then throw away.
00:47:13 However, other aspects,
00:47:16 anti-static coatings of photographic film.
00:47:19 Bayer, a company in Germany,
00:47:22 developed a very nice, what is called a poly-fiber derivative called PEDOT.
00:47:26 All of Agfa photographic color film for the last couple of years
00:47:32 has been coated with the PEDOT as an anti-static material
00:47:37 because apparently if you roll quickly photographic film
00:47:42 and the humidity is not right,
00:47:44 you'll get a lot of charge built up and you'll get sparks occurring
00:47:47 and that can make the film.
00:47:49 And what I've heard by the grapevine
00:47:52 that Fuji, Fujifilm in Japan and also Kodak
00:47:57 might be using the same technique.
00:48:00 Corrosion prevention metal, polyethylene,
00:48:02 a lot of work being done in slowing down corrosion of iron and steel.
00:48:10 Polypyrrole capacitors,
00:48:12 and many of these are now about millions have been made in Japan.
00:48:16 Electromagnetic interference for shielding radar,
00:48:20 I'll show an example of that shortly.
00:48:22 Anti-static floor tiles,
00:48:23 I'll show an example of that.
00:48:25 Rechargeable batteries,
00:48:26 I'll show an example of that.
00:48:28 Transparent electrodes,
00:48:29 electro-crystal displays,
00:48:31 we'll touch on that.
00:48:32 Non-linear optical for optical transmission
00:48:35 instead of electronic transmission.
00:48:37 Radar avoidance,
00:48:39 gas separation membrane,
00:48:40 biochemical sensors,
00:48:41 some of these have been made for glucose.
00:48:44 Sensors for volatile organic compounds,
00:48:46 solar cells,
00:48:47 drug-releasing polymers,
00:48:48 plastic chips,
00:48:49 which I'll mention some,
00:48:51 and also these throwaway devices.
00:48:53 One other thing that I just added by hand here,
00:48:57 and I haven't had a chance yet to type it in,
00:49:00 and that is because of the discovery of magnetic material
00:49:07 by Joel Miller,
00:49:08 University of Utah,
00:49:09 and working with Epstein at Ohio State.
00:49:13 Now, one can have completely organic ferromagnets.
00:49:17 Since then this opens the possibility
00:49:21 of then having completely plastic electric motors,
00:49:25 your organic magnetic material
00:49:28 and conductance polymer wiring,
00:49:31 and therefore also completely plastic generators.
00:49:36 As an example here,
00:49:39 some of these rechargeable batteries
00:49:42 based on the pen patterns in the field.
00:49:46 The key property of these
00:49:49 is that they have a very low self-discharge.
00:49:52 If you have an automobile battery
00:49:54 and you've got to wait for car heating six months
00:49:57 to come back and try and start the car,
00:49:59 it's not going to want to start too well.
00:50:01 These have a very low discharge rate
00:50:05 and possible use then as backup for memories of computers.
00:50:12 The Millikan company,
00:50:16 Hans Kuhn, a good friend,
00:50:18 has made some of the...
00:50:21 He found that he can coat any type of fabric,
00:50:25 natural, cotton wool, silk,
00:50:27 or synthetics with varying thicknesses
00:50:32 of polypyrrole or polyaniline.
00:50:34 And these were used in the Gulf War
00:50:38 by putting big throw sheets over tanks
00:50:41 or planes or guns on the ground.
00:50:43 And if you adjust the conductivity correctly,
00:50:46 you can then shine a radar gun at these
00:50:49 and you get the same response
00:50:51 if you shine a radar gun through outer space
00:50:54 and nothing is reflected.
00:50:57 So there are many, many aspects in this.
00:51:01 Also, for antistatic portiles, et cetera,
00:51:10 these then are made by Nestle, a company in Finland.
00:51:17 So these are polyvinyl chloride, PVC portiles
00:51:21 with polyaniline in them
00:51:23 for operating theaters for pores
00:51:29 where one is dealing with explosives.
00:51:32 And now in China, I understand these are coming out
00:51:35 as materials for the soles of your shoes
00:51:40 when that is not a concern.
00:51:43 So to finally summarize here,
00:51:48 I'd like to share with you...
00:51:52 So we've mentioned here how Alan Hegar
00:51:59 had developed the work that he had done at Penn
00:52:03 and also work that others have done
00:52:05 around the world on conducting polymers
00:52:07 to develop his company, Uniax,
00:52:12 for making these light-emitting displays
00:52:16 and which is now being then, a few months ago,
00:52:19 sold on to DuPont.
00:52:20 And of course, DuPont is very actively involved
00:52:23 in this whole area of light-emitting displays.
00:52:27 And other possible uses,
00:52:30 people have even suggested a wallpaper for rooms in Sweden.
00:52:37 I went to one research institute
00:52:39 where they showed a virtual room,
00:52:41 which is a room of all square walls.
00:52:43 If you look over there, you can see a beautiful window
00:52:45 and a beautiful fireplace there,
00:52:47 all in the fashion of the wallpaper.
00:52:50 I think that's a real genuine thing,
00:52:52 but that's life.
00:52:54 So now I want to touch on this.
00:53:01 About 10 months ago,
00:53:02 our group had filed about three patents
00:53:07 with our, given disclosures, rather,
00:53:12 to the Penn Center of Technology and Transfer.
00:53:19 Then the, essentially unknown to us,
00:53:22 the Penn Center of Technology and Transfer,
00:53:27 sort of like these,
00:53:29 and they got some financial backing.
00:53:32 And then they then received money
00:53:37 from venture capital people.
00:53:38 Venture capital people then set up a company,
00:53:42 Ecomerix, which was started off in Delaware.
00:53:48 And so this then is, I think,
00:53:50 an extremely good example of technology transfer.
00:53:54 And this is being done more and more, I find,
00:53:57 in moving around the world,
00:53:59 that universities are making a concerted effort
00:54:06 to get their technology,
00:54:09 get the basic chemical findings
00:54:11 or scientific findings into technology.
00:54:15 And the answer is, why should they want to do that?
00:54:18 As Penn says, Penn is not in the business
00:54:21 of making money out of patents.
00:54:23 But if you do make money out of it, fine.
00:54:27 It really, there is very much more fundamentally.
00:54:32 If, in other words, where does the money come from?
00:54:36 That the people in Congress
00:54:38 or congressional committees will give money, say,
00:54:42 to the Department of Defense,
00:54:44 the National Science Foundation,
00:54:46 National Institute of Health.
00:54:49 This comes out of people's pockets as taxpayers.
00:54:53 It disappears.
00:54:54 Now, in order for the politicians,
00:54:57 for the heads of the various funding agencies
00:55:01 to appear good to their bosses
00:55:03 and for politicians to appear good to their constituency,
00:55:08 you have to show the constituency
00:55:11 that the money is done somewhere.
00:55:13 So, in other words, if we, coming down further,
00:55:16 if the university can then say,
00:55:19 okay, we have patented,
00:55:21 we've helped get transferred some of the basic findings
00:55:25 into technology,
00:55:27 then that looks good
00:55:29 when people are applying for support,
00:55:32 financial support from various agencies,
00:55:34 for example, from Penn.
00:55:36 It can be let known that Penn is active
00:55:40 in transferring basic research to technology,
00:55:43 and the funding agents love to hear that,
00:55:45 and they can put that in their anger reports
00:55:47 to their next group of bosses higher up,
00:55:49 who can then put them on the next higher up one in Congress.
00:55:53 So, it's very good public relations,
00:55:56 apart from anything else,
00:55:57 such from selfish motivations,
00:55:58 but from the scientific viewpoint, of course,
00:56:01 it's great to really have a method
00:56:05 to do this transfer.
00:56:07 In the past,
00:56:08 and we have about 20-odd patents,
00:56:10 which we filed in the last several decades,
00:56:13 it was happenstance.
00:56:15 We, or Penn, would file the patents,
00:56:17 and if somebody happened to hear about it,
00:56:19 then they could contact Penn,
00:56:21 and maybe, yes, maybe no,
00:56:25 nobody was very interested in the university
00:56:27 and wasting time on all this patent stuff.
00:56:30 But now, a couple of years ago,
00:56:32 a new department was made with its own personnel
00:56:36 involving both scientists and lawyers,
00:56:38 particularly scientists who have a training in law,
00:56:41 lawyers who have a training in science.
00:56:43 And we, personally, and other institutions,
00:56:47 find this very, very helpful.
00:56:49 I was down a few weeks ago
00:56:51 speaking to the vice-chancellor
00:56:53 and the president of the University of Wollongong,
00:56:55 one of the key active universities in Australia,
00:56:58 and what we were saying,
00:56:59 now, the world is a small place.
00:57:02 Instead of we trying to do something here,
00:57:06 other here, and saying,
00:57:07 well, we must fight other people,
00:57:11 we say, let's join together.
00:57:13 Why don't we have an internet poll
00:57:16 of each organization, each university,
00:57:20 list the titles and the abstracts
00:57:22 of all of the patents that they have filed
00:57:25 within a given time period,
00:57:27 and then this will be open to venture capitalists,
00:57:31 to other industries who can look through and say,
00:57:34 okay, maybe if we can take one patent
00:57:36 from this place in China,
00:57:38 one from this place in Australia,
00:57:40 one from here in the U.S.,
00:57:42 and one from Russia,
00:57:43 and one from Italy,
00:57:44 and get these, combine these,
00:57:47 this could be a good juicy morsel.
00:57:49 But when each of these are trying separately
00:57:52 to exploit this patent,
00:57:53 then you're lost,
00:57:55 you're spreading things too thinly.
00:57:58 I think we're going to see this very much more,
00:58:01 that we're putting the patents
00:58:03 and the abstracts on the internet,
00:58:07 and then people will,
00:58:09 can pick patents from any part of the world.
00:58:11 We're a small, we're a small place now.
00:58:14 So we've got to think small and cohesively
00:58:17 rather than each person looks after their own fate.
00:58:20 Anyway, so just to give some idea
00:58:24 of how things are going,
00:58:26 this is a plastic chip.
00:58:28 This is developed at Philips company in Anheuser
00:58:31 in the Netherlands,
00:58:32 and Philips company is one of the,
00:58:35 the biggest electronics companies in Europe.
00:58:39 I actually have a videotape
00:58:41 that Philips gave me of this,
00:58:43 and I'll describe that in just a second.
00:58:45 So this then is a plastic chip.
00:58:47 It's about the size of a 50 cent piece.
00:58:50 It costs about one cent each.
00:58:53 It's flexible.
00:58:55 You can hold it up to the light,
00:58:56 and you can just make out the polyamory
00:58:58 and wire it through it.
00:59:00 And their first use is to replace the barcodes
00:59:03 on goods in the supermarket
00:59:05 with one of these plastic chips.
00:59:07 On this video, I had it show the person
00:59:10 with their shopping basket loaded up with goods.
00:59:13 They wheel it past the checkout counter.
00:59:15 By the time the wheels have stopped getting around,
00:59:17 the cost of all of the goods has been added up
00:59:19 and the cost has been reduced.
00:59:21 And this, of course, is quite simple.
00:59:30 We have an antenna here to
00:59:34 The pure electromagnet's wave coming out is picked up here, makes a small amount of electricity, and that then activates its own transmitter.
00:59:44 And the transmitted signal characteristic of that good then is picked up.
00:59:50 This will never replace the silicon chips in, say, outer space.
00:59:54 As Phillips Company says, the shelf life of this chip is about six months.
00:59:59 On the other hand, they say that hopefully the shelf life of most of the goods in supermarkets is not that long.
01:00:07 So in other words, it's a one-use-only and throw-it-away.
01:00:12 So we've had some very good interactions with Phillips.
01:00:16 They are wanting to go smaller and smaller and smaller, as I'll mention very briefly in a minute.
01:00:21 We are not interested in going smaller. If we can go smaller, we will.
01:00:25 We want to go cheap, cheap, cheap, cheap, cheap.
01:00:27 So this is what we call line patterning of conducting polymers.
01:00:34 We feel that this whole area of disposable electronics is, well, it will be surrounded by them very, very quickly indeed.
01:00:47 Electronic circuits that cost no more than costing to Xerox a print piece of a letter.
01:00:57 So a number of groups throughout the world are doing very, very nice work on using conducting polymers as inks to print conducting patterns.
01:01:09 And that is great.
01:01:11 We are interested in something even cheaper, and that is by a method which does not involve any printing of a conducting polymer.
01:01:20 It does not involve printing of a conducting polymer. It does not involve printing of a conducting polymer.
01:01:26 Instead, what one does, we make use of the difference in hydrophilicity, hydrophilicity, wettability of the toner line from the regular office printer and the substrate.
01:01:42 The substrate being plastic, paper, or fabric.
01:01:45 Here, I'll just use as an example all the time, plastic, and we're just using an overhead transparency, which all of us use all the time.
01:01:55 So what one does then, you'll print some pattern. I'll show a couple of these in a moment.
01:02:02 Make the pattern on the computer, reduce it to any size you like, and then print it out either on paper or on overhead transparency.
01:02:13 Now, the toner lines are insulated.
01:02:17 And here you then spray on or wipe on a thin layer of conducting polymer.
01:02:24 Then here, this is conducting, but they're all separated by insulating toner lines.
01:02:30 So now then, you've made a pattern, a conducting pattern, without, just by using the printer in the office, or we did this first of all in the office Xerox machine, without any modification of the machine.
01:02:45 Now, just to give one quick example.
01:02:48 This, we're working with a company for liquid crystal displays.
01:02:53 So, on the computer then, this was Dick from Holtz in my lab.
01:03:00 Through this pattern, this is a print outlined to a pinch.
01:03:06 And then what we do is put a drop of commercial liquid crystal display liquid there.
01:03:13 Then put another one down on top, push it with your finger.
01:03:17 Now, you've got 25 by 25, that's 625 pixels per square inch.
01:03:23 We've actually demonstrated about 10 months ago, working on this as an office of naval research contractors review meeting.
01:03:31 So, then if you, and that works fine.
01:03:35 But, on the other hand, we're working with a display company, you'll know, and,
01:03:47 Anybody have a, thank you.
01:03:50 Oh, I have one right here.
01:03:52 Oh, thank you.
01:03:54 Okay, thanks for, I'll promise to do it back.
01:03:57 I've watched you.
01:04:02 Right, thanks.
01:04:04 So, but if you want to remove the toner line, we find we can do that very, very easily.
01:04:11 You take one of these things, you put them to toluene for about six or seven seconds,
01:04:18 using ultrasonic heat in the lab for washing glassware.
01:04:21 It removes all of the toner line, and you're left then just with the conducting polymer line.
01:04:27 So, as I tell my students, this is the first time I'm really pleased to have a transparency,
01:04:34 and I hope the audience can't see it.
01:04:36 Because, here then, we have electrode lines that are 93% transmissive in the visible region.
01:04:46 They are flexible, and, of course, can be made extremely cheaply.
01:04:50 We also demonstrated this review of making 100 lines per inch,
01:04:57 and 100 times 100 is 10,000 pixels per square inch,
01:05:01 which we had as a working model with the crystal display.
01:05:05 So, many, we feel there are many extensions for this,
01:05:10 and, indeed, this is the company that came.
01:05:14 And, again, I say, without us really doing anything.
01:05:17 They sort of told me that it wasn't okay with me if they tried to form a company,
01:05:25 and I said, well, if you do that sort of thing, that's great.
01:05:28 Let me know.
01:05:30 So, this is, I think, a real example where, as I said,
01:05:35 leave the scientists alone to do their science.
01:05:38 Let the business people do their thing,
01:05:40 and hopefully sort of talk to each other somewhere along the way.
01:05:45 Now, so, if we go away from liquid crystal aspects altogether,
01:05:52 and then just look at electronic circuits,
01:05:57 we can make them three-dimensional by just using a paper stapler on my desk,
01:06:02 and the top part of the staple is metal, makes a connection here,
01:06:07 goes through the insulating, and hits the bottom part.
01:06:10 So, one can go on and on.
01:06:13 I'll miss out on a number of things here.
01:06:15 But just to finish, then, with a field effect transistor, an FET,
01:06:23 as we know that one of the key things in any piece of electronic equipment
01:06:33 is a transistor which amplifies the signal going through.
01:06:38 So, here, then, we have one.
01:06:41 You can see the relative size here,
01:06:43 made just completely in the lab using the office printer,
01:06:48 and very, very cheap indeed.
01:06:54 This is just showing it on a larger scale.
01:06:58 Here, then, we have Dignori-Okazaki made this.
01:07:04 This is one of them here.
01:07:05 As you can see, you can make them by the dozen.
01:07:10 At the moment, it's rather slow, but we feel we can make it faster.
01:07:17 And, indeed, depending on what you use it for,
01:07:21 this will probably never be used for television screens,
01:07:23 but for little tag devices.
01:07:26 Then, if you have it seconds away, quite often that will not matter.
01:07:31 And the characteristics of this are really very, very good
01:07:39 compared with regular transistors.
01:07:42 So, we feel, then, there's this whole area of disposal of plastic electronics
01:07:49 which is really just around the corner.
01:07:52 During the last 35 years,
01:07:54 so much is being found out in the electronic polymers,
01:08:02 and now we feel that there's very high probability,
01:08:08 and, apparently, some venture capital people feel the same way,
01:08:12 of really developing an industry in literally throw-away electronics
01:08:18 where one might have the electronic equipment for one use only.
01:08:24 Or, if one is considering, say, solar cells,
01:08:27 the solar cells that can be made from these plastics,
01:08:34 from electronic conducting polymers,
01:08:36 the efficiency is really very, very low.
01:08:39 So, the point is, rather than trying to push up the efficiency
01:08:43 and try to copy what is done by classical solar cells,
01:08:48 if you can't fight it, then join it.
01:08:51 Print out a great big piece of plastic, this big,
01:08:54 with 10,000 solar cells on it,
01:08:57 and put them together in series in whatever way you want.
01:09:03 If it only lasts for six months, maybe it's fine for certain things,
01:09:07 maybe not for other things.
01:09:09 But, again, whether you're going to manufacture something
01:09:13 depends on two things.
01:09:15 What do you want to use it for, and how much does it cost?
01:09:18 And, as we know, if you're going to compete with something on the market,
01:09:22 then you either have to have the same properties at a cheaper price,
01:09:26 or you have to have the same price but better properties.
01:09:29 But, it's what one has to think big, one has to expand one's mind.
01:09:37 Same sort of thing, I say, if somebody says to you,
01:09:39 which is the better airplane, a jumbo jet or a 16C that says that,
01:09:44 you can't answer the question.
01:09:45 You have to say, what for?
01:09:47 From flying from Denver to Newark or across the Atlantic.
01:09:50 So, the same sort of thing with any of the things that one looks at in the lab.
01:09:59 What use would one want to consider it for, and at what cost?
01:10:06 For many years, we have quite often in the field said
01:10:12 that the whole area of conducting polymers was indeed the answer
01:10:21 waiting for the appropriate question to be asked.
01:10:25 Now, we feel that time is upon us.
01:10:28 So, after 25 years in the field, our feeling is the following,
01:10:33 that the basic chemistry and physics of electronic polymers, plastics,
01:10:38 the basic chemistry has now been discovered.
01:10:42 So, what we really have then is something like a plum tree
01:10:46 with a lot of juicy red plums hanging from the branches,
01:10:50 and technology is now picking off some of these plums
01:10:55 and is exploiting what has already been found out.
01:11:00 However, new things, we believe the whole area here
01:11:07 will be technology driven from now on.
01:11:10 However, while one is shooting for technological objectives,
01:11:17 new science will be found.
01:11:19 Just as we can see here, five months ago, four months ago,
01:11:23 with superconductivity in an organic polymer
01:11:26 done by Lucent Lab's spinel from Bell Labs,
01:11:31 technology driven, they are looking for new uses
01:11:36 and specific objectives in conducting polymers.
01:11:40 But, completely new phenomena is discovered along the way.
01:11:46 So, if one is then talking about the future,
01:11:51 it's always fun to crystal ball days,
01:11:56 where you get a data point which is way off the line.
01:12:02 All of us, I know, have got this happening at times,
01:12:06 and when that happens, it's a real pain in the backside.
01:12:11 It really is annoying.
01:12:13 So, the technician will tend to say,
01:12:16 well, that fell off the line, so we'll forget about it.
01:12:18 It must be wrong, an experimental error,
01:12:21 so let's forget about that.
01:12:23 The real research scientists will worry about it,
01:12:26 and wake up in the middle of the night,
01:12:28 because he or she might think, yeah, we'll throw it away,
01:12:30 and wake up in the middle of the night,
01:12:32 but I don't feel comfortable about throwing it away.
01:12:34 Let's go back and double-check it.
01:12:36 And if it comes back on the line, then everybody's happy.
01:12:38 But if it stays out there again, then it's even more worrisome,
01:12:42 because now you're being able to repeat it.
01:12:44 And if you repeat it enough, then, of course,
01:12:45 this is where you get new concepts developing.
01:12:49 So, I'm sure that science in this field,
01:12:52 and all of the areas of basic science,
01:12:55 and the development into technology,
01:12:58 will continue by all of these three methods.
01:13:01 So, unfortunately, there are far too many people
01:13:06 to mention who have contributed.
01:13:09 Here, early studies, collaboration with Alan Hegar
01:13:12 and Hideki Shirakawa,
01:13:13 and to many, many, many undergraduate, graduate students
01:13:17 and postdoc fellows,
01:13:19 and the principal support by the Office of Native Research
01:13:22 and the Pennsylvania Material Science Lab.
01:13:25 And then, when Alan Hegar left to go to California,
01:13:30 then, for physics support,
01:13:33 we were collaborating very strongly with my friend,
01:13:36 colleague Epstein of Ohio State,
01:13:39 and again, many, many persons,
01:13:40 and again, similar scientific support as from here.
01:13:45 And in the nanofibers,
01:13:47 we were introduced to this area by Professor Frank Coe
01:13:51 from Drexel here,
01:13:53 and we've been having a very good collaborative program
01:13:57 in this, and still going ahead strongly,
01:14:00 and supported by the U.S. Office of Native Research,
01:14:04 and also the Army Research Office,
01:14:07 and the line patterning,
01:14:08 which I didn't have time to mention tonight.
01:14:10 This is getting to the nanoscience area.
01:14:13 But, in particular, I want to mention Ken Nguyen.
01:14:19 Ken Nguyen was my contracting officer
01:14:23 in the Office of Native Research
01:14:25 for 25 years or more.
01:14:28 He has now retired,
01:14:30 and has now taken on the university post,
01:14:33 so I can talk about him and say good things about him.
01:14:36 He thinks I'm not apple polishing.
01:14:38 But he was the first person in the world
01:14:41 to put any money into his whole area
01:14:45 on which the prize was given.
01:14:49 And he did it really for no scientific reason at all,
01:14:53 but had a hunch that maybe it would be okay.
01:14:57 So, the funding agencies
01:15:01 and the project directors in all countries,
01:15:06 in my opinion,
01:15:08 are some of the most influential
01:15:11 and important people in science today.
01:15:15 Depending on what they fund or do not fund,
01:15:19 they then determine the course of basic science
01:15:23 and of technology in that country
01:15:28 10 years, 20 years from now.
01:15:30 I think, again,
01:15:32 that the funding officer
01:15:37 or the organization
01:15:40 so much is in charge of the technology
01:15:44 10 to 20 years hence,
01:15:46 depending on what they fund.
01:15:48 We had a very, very interesting
01:15:50 one-hour roundtable discussion
01:15:53 in the library in the Royal Palace in Stockholm
01:15:57 with all of the Nobel awardees this year,
01:15:59 in all the various fields.
01:16:01 One of the things that cropped up,
01:16:05 after I first mentioned the word moonlighting,
01:16:09 a lot of the basic research
01:16:11 on all of this electronic stuff
01:16:14 was done by moonlighting.
01:16:16 In other words,
01:16:18 we were doing the work illegally.
01:16:20 In other words,
01:16:22 we had a grant on another project,
01:16:24 but the project was on the other side.
01:16:27 When I mentioned this,
01:16:29 I remember Gail over here
01:16:32 was sitting beside Alan Keater's wife
01:16:34 in closed-circuit television.
01:16:36 Alan Keater's wife said,
01:16:38 Alan shouldn't have mentioned something like that,
01:16:40 moonlighting.
01:16:42 That was then picked up by a whole group
01:16:44 and it's been on BBC.
01:16:46 Everybody in the group said
01:16:48 that they had all done moonlighting.
01:16:50 This most important work was done on moonlighting
01:16:53 because it was so highly speculated
01:16:56 that if you put it in
01:16:58 to get funded from an agency,
01:17:00 it would be turned down.
01:17:02 You've got a hunch,
01:17:04 but hunches are not good
01:17:06 in research proposals.
01:17:08 You have to have good, solid data.
01:17:10 Hunches don't work
01:17:12 when you're applying for money.
01:17:14 But if you do it on the side,
01:17:16 illegally,
01:17:18 then one or two percent
01:17:20 of the hunches might work.
01:17:22 When they do work,
01:17:24 then you can get funded.
01:17:26 Gentlemen, ladies,
01:17:28 I'm afraid I've spoken much longer
01:17:30 than I should have,
01:17:32 but thank you very much
01:17:34 for your kind attention.
01:17:36 See you guys in a bit.
01:17:38 Thank you.
01:17:40 Yeah, I will.
01:17:53 Three items in closure.
01:17:56 First, most mundane.
01:17:59 Those of you who parked
01:18:01 in the garage at the Bourse,
01:18:03 if you take your ticket
01:18:05 to the front desk,
01:18:07 you can get it stamped
01:18:09 and get something off the parking fee.
01:18:11 Second and slightly more elevated,
01:18:13 if you go to the front of the building
01:18:15 and take the elevators
01:18:17 to the third floor,
01:18:19 that is where we are having
01:18:21 our reception,
01:18:23 at which there will be
01:18:24 a conversation with Alan
01:18:26 and ask him all those questions
01:18:28 that have been provoked
01:18:30 by what he had to say.
01:18:32 Third and most elevated,
01:18:34 Alan, I think we are all
01:18:36 delighted to have
01:18:38 this very vivid
01:18:40 exemplification
01:18:42 that the tradition
01:18:44 of research inquiry
01:18:46 and ingenuity
01:18:48 that Benjamin Rush
01:18:50 and Benjamin Franklin
01:18:52 launched here in Philadelphia
01:18:54 live and well
01:18:56 and we thank you.